Two findings from the same Muck Rack survey explain why pitching feels futile and why it still works for the people who do it properly.
Founders tend to hold one of two beliefs about media pitching. It either does nothing, or it is a volume game.
Muck Rack’s 2025 State of Journalism survey of 1,890 journalists contradicts both, and it does so with two numbers that sit a few pages apart.
The door is open
84% of journalists surveyed said at least some of their stories originate from PR pitches. Only 16% said none do.
Cision’s 2026 State of the Media Report, covering 1,899 journalists across 19 markets, found something adjacent: 66% rely on PR-provided content for story ideas.
Reporters are not shutting out outside input. They are drowning in the wrong kind.
The door is also narrow
86% of journalists in the Muck Rack survey said they immediately disregard irrelevant pitches.
Cision supplies the scale of the problem. 72% of journalists said fewer than a quarter of the pitches they receive are relevant to them at all.
Put the two surveys together and the picture is clear. Most of the inbox is noise, and reporters have built a reflex for clearing it.
Two other ways to get cleared out fast
71% of the journalists surveyed said they dislike overly promotional pitches. 50% said the same about mass emails.
Those two preferences describe the standard agency send: one announcement, adjectives attached, distributed to a list.
The approach that feels efficient trips the two filters a reporter uses most.
Silence is the baseline, and it is not personal
54% of journalists said they seldom or never respond to pitches.
Cision offers the reason without excusing it: 49% named shrinking budgets, staff cuts and heavier workloads as their biggest obstacle.
A reporter covering what two reporters used to cover does not have the minutes to decline politely. Build your follow-up plan around that fact.
What buys you consideration
The same survey asked the positive version of the question. 69% said a pitch is worth their time if it is clearly tailored to their beat.
44% named access to a credible source, and 41% cited relevant data or research.
Tailoring leads the list by a wide margin, which means the scarce resource in pitching is reading, not writing.
The arithmetic of a narrow list
Say you spend a morning on twelve pitches to a scraped list. The 86% reflex handles most of them before anyone reads a second sentence.
Spend the same morning reading four reporters’ recent work and writing four notes that reference it, and you are pitching into the 69% condition instead.
I run Subscribe PR in Phoenix, and the shift I ask founders to make is from a send list to a reading list.
Relationships are still half the job
50% of journalists said PR relationships are important or very important to their success. The channel is not hostile to you. It is hostile to being treated as a distribution list.
Start with the reporters already covering your subject, and write to them as readers of their own work.
If you want to see how this gets run on a sustained basis, the write-ups are at calebhellinger.com/insights.
Caleb Hellinger runs Subscribe PR, an answer engine optimization and digital PR agency in Phoenix.
